About Sunset Pizzeria Brewster
Tucked along 983 NY-22 in Brewster, NY, Sunset Pizzeria Brewster is the kind of local spot where comfort food meets casual dining. The atmosphere is relaxed, welcoming families, groups of friends, and anyone craving a satisfying bite. It’s not just another restaurant on the map-it’s a place where the menu reflects a mix of tradition and hearty favorites that keep regulars coming back.
The first thing many guests notice is the wide selection of pizzas. The Grandma Pie, with its perfectly crisp crust and balanced tomato sauce, is a favorite that has earned plenty of good reviews from locals. For those who like a lighter but flavorful option, the Veggie Pizza offers generous toppings without skimping on taste. Beyond pizza, there’s plenty more to explore, like the creamy Penne Alla Vodka, which feels like a warm hug in a bowl.
Meat lovers often gravitate toward the Sausage Roll, a baked classic that pairs flaky dough with a savory filling, while the Philly Cheesesteak has built its own loyal fan base with tender slices of beef and melted cheese layered into a soft roll. These signature dishes give the restaurant’s menu a nice balance between Italian-inspired comfort food and hearty diner favorites.
When it comes to services, convenience plays a big role. Families appreciate the availability of high chairs, making dining out with little ones less stressful. For drivers, the free parking lot is a big plus-no circling the block to find a space. Sunset Pizzeria Brewster also keeps late-night appetites in mind, offering food well past typical dinner hours. And if you’re not looking for a full meal, the small plates are a great way to share and sample different flavors without overindulging.
Between the warm service, on-site dining, and a variety of choices that fit both quick bites and sit-down meals, this spot has become a staple in its location. Whether someone is stopping by after work or meeting friends on the weekend, it’s easy to see why the restaurant has earned such a loyal following in the Brewster community.
Location
Opening Time
Restaurant Services
Service options
- Kerbside pickup
- No-contact delivery
- Delivery
- On-site services
- Takeaway
- Dine-in
Popular for
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Solo dining
Accessibility
- Wheelchair-accessible car park
- Wheelchair-accessible entrance
- Wheelchair-accessible seating
Offerings
- Comfort food
- Late-night food
- Quick bite
- Small plates
- Vegetarian options
Dining options
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Catering
- Dessert
- Seating
Atmosphere
- Casual
- Cosy
Crowd
- Family friendly
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Children
- Good for kids
- High chairs
Parking
- Free of charge street parking
- Free parking lot
- On-site parking
- Parking
Sunset Pizzeria Brewster Gallery
Customer Reviews
“ Great food, great experience while dining! Most places I feel grab your food and go. The interaction, and level of care the employees bring make this place a five star experience. Food quality is unmatched! Grandma and vodka margarita slices are an instant go to! ”
“ Just had some pizza at Sunset pizzeria and wow—this one’s a winner. The crust was perfectly crisp on the outside, soft on the inside. The sauce had real depth (you can tell it’s made in-house), and the cheese? Stretchy, melty, and just the right amount. Toppings were fresh and generously loaded. 10/10 would order again. ”
“ I stopped by about a month ago I heard it’s under New management. It’s very clean. I ordered 2 slices of pizza It was great. The crust was crispy and had good flavor it did not taste like cardboard. Now every time I drive through Brewster, .next time I hear that the lasagna fettuccine Alfredo is fantastic. ”
“ This place is very nice! Clean, quick service, and delicious pizza. Mozzarella sticks, onion wings, salads wraps eat in or to go. A great recommendation if in the Brewster area. ”
“ Sunset Pizzeria Brewster – Solid Spot for a Good Meal Stopped by Sunset Pizzeria in Brewster and was pleasantly surprised. I ordered the linguine with clam sauce and the orecchiette pasta, and both were really well done. The linguine had great flavor—light, garlicky, and loaded with fresh clams. It tasted homemade in the best way. The orecchiette was just as good—tender, perfectly cooked, and the sauce had a nice depth to it. You can tell they put care into what they’re serving. The place has a relaxed vibe and the staff was friendly. It’s not fancy, but it’s the kind of spot where you can sit down, enjoy your food, and leave full and satisfied. I’d definitely come back. ”
“ Loved the service, and the pizza and other meals were really good! I'll definitely be coming here for my pizza from now on! ”
“ Awesome NY-style pizza! Perfect balance of cheese, sauce, and dough — reheats very well. Chicken parm hero was great too. Super clean place with easy parking. This is our new favorite spot—can’t wait to try more! ”
